Talking-up Scotland

In the Guardian today, we see this very gloomy graphic:

Needless to say, there is no reference to differences within the parts of the UK such as Scotland and so no sign of the dramatic growth of Scottish energy production which will have been a major part of the Q1 surplus and without which the Q2 deficit, due in part to lack of wind, would have been even more worrying.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/aug/10/british-manufacturing-in-recession-despite-faster-uk-gdp-growth

These statements give an idea of Scotland’s massive over-production of energy:

• 9% energy of consumption
• 82% of oil production
• 50% of gas production
• 25% of coal production
• offshore renewables resource estimated at 206 GW – 30 times peak demand
• 29% of electricity exported to the rest of the UK
• renewables capacity at 7 gigawatts well on way to meeting our baseline target of 100% of gross annual electricity demand by 2020.’
• currently meets 100% of indigenous demand from conventional sources, mainly nuclear, coal and hydro

Sources:

https://www.gov.scot/Topics/Business-Industry/Energy/Energy-sources

www.gov.scot/Topics/Statistics/Browse/Economy/oilgas1617

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/579618/Regional_Electricity_Generation_and_Supply.pdf

 

(c) (Image: Steve McKendrick)

In the Scotsman today, we read:

‘Brian Wilson: Does Scotland actually care about education?’

At first when I see the words ‘Brian Wilson’, I think ‘God only knows what I’d be without you’ and I begin to feel good vibrations but then when I see it’s that wee Labour guy from the 70s and 80s, my spirits sink before I even read:

‘Does Scotland, as a society, really care about education? A decade ago, the question would have verged on the sacreligious. Education was our USP. The best in the world, we used to boast. Faith in the democratic intellect shaped our self-image. Always a little over-egged but with at least a basis of historic truth. Look at us now. Further down the international league tables than the Scottish football team for whom it is not an option to stop publishing results which is the Scottish Government’s preferred tactic on literacy and numeracy.’

https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/brian-wilson-does-scotland-actually-care-about-education-1-4782050

Leaving aside the wrong spelling of ‘sacriligious’ (that’s what Word puts the red line under for Brian), the article is rambling, confused, evidence-free, just wrong. I cannot bear to do him the honour of a line-by-line dismissal (He’s not warf it, Jonn!) but will restrict myself to suggesting some reading that might help:

Educational attainment gaps much smaller in Scotland than in England after 10 years of SNP government: JRF Poverty Report Extract 6

Figures show majority of Scottish school pupils are performing well as England’s educational policy makers dither

Closing Scotland’s Education Gap: The Herald’s ‘education guru’ is on the wrong track

Scotland’s school’s PISA results ‘lean’ toward nothing meaningful. Finland’s success is not real. South Korea and China’s educational programmes amount to child abuse

Herald’s emeritus professor gets it wrong on alleged teacher shortages in Scotland’s schools which are much better staffed than those in England

SNP continues to build far more schools than Labour did/could

97% of Scotland’s head teachers expect attainment gap to close over next five years thanks to SNP government funding

BBC Scotland’s wilful mis-represenation on literacy levels

Ruth Davidson’s chaotic attack on school standards is ignorant

SNP Government increases teacher numbers to create far superior pupil/teacher ratios and much smaller attainment gaps than in England

 

 

(c) vimeo.com

At least this time the Scotsman makes it clear, in the headline, that they are acting merely on behalf of the Tory press office. Usually, they bury the named Unionist politician several paragraphs in, where few of their readers tread or should that be read?

Today, we could read:

‘The comparison between the First Minister and Dr Richard Beeching, who axed railways in the 1960s, was made by Shadow Health Secretary Miles Briggs ahead of a visit to Orkney. Mr Briggs blamed the Scottish Government for a series of NHS cuts outside Scotland’s big cities in places like West Lothian, Perthshire and the Highlands.’

We do eventually get the SNP response, but nobody is reading now, apart from me:

‘But the SNP dismissed Mr Briggs’s remarks as “laughable” and pointed out that it was the Conservative party which established the Beeching Review that was to lead to the closure of many rural railways.’

https://www.scotsman.com/news/tories-say-nicola-sturgeon-is-the-nhs-s-dr-richard-beeching-1-4782381

Miles Briggs gets to say more stuff and, typically, its evidence-free, so here’s some evidence he could do with reading:

At 78% level of satisfaction with NHS Scotland is impressive 36% higher than for the NHS across UK

NHS England sees 35% increase in patients waiting more than 18 weeks while NHS Scotland reports a fall of 0.2% despite a 14.6% increase in demand

NHS Scotland: 27% increase in kidney transplants including 10% increase from living donors as ‘UK’ level falls to eight-year low

Bed-blocking in NHS Scotland falls by nearly 10% in one year as the rate in NHS England surges to nearly 500% higher, per capita, than that in NHS Scotland!

National auditors find two very different NHS systems in the UK. Someone tell Theresa today.

NHS Scotland significantly outperforms NHS England on cancer waiting times despite demand soaring: Herald fails to report properly again

 

(c) Scottish Business News Network

As business and tourism boom in Scotland, we read in Insider today:

‘Investment into Scottish hotels doubled in the first half of the year to almost £400m, according to new figures. UK buyers were the biggest buying group, accounting for 41 per cent of activity, followed by Middle Eastern investors (22 per cent of transactional volume), Israeli investors (16 per cent), US investors (8 per cent), Canadian Investors (7 per cent), Singaporean investors (5 per cent) and German investors (1 per cent). Collectively, non-domestic investors continue to be the dominant player in the market.’

As in many other contexts, the Scottish situation seems more promising than that in the non-Scottish parts of the UK:

‘Looking at the UK as a whole, Savills research shows a total of £3.2 billion has been invested into hotels in the first six months of the year, with Scotland accounting for 13 per cent of investment in terms of value.’

Bottom of Form

https://www.insider.co.uk/news/scottish-hotel-investment-doubles-savills-13056200

Other 8% stories:

Only 8% of the population but 50% to 75% of the removal of highly toxic pollutants. How Scotland’s natural assets are helping rid British air of pollutants

8% of the population, nearly 9% of the exports but only 5.25% of the imports

Return of the meme? Only 8% of the population but Scotland has 21.7% of all independent renewable projects in the UK

Still 8% of the population but now 30% of UK food and drink exports?

8% of the UK population and 28% of living wage employers. More evidence that we are different enough to want to run the whole show?

With only 8% of the population, Scotland’s maritime sector accounts for 25% of the UK maritime sector’s (GVA) contribution to the economy and is 17.5% more productive than the UK marine oil and gas sector. Once more, too wee, too poor?

Once again, it’s the ‘8% of the UK population but much more of something good’ meme. This time it’s 33% of employee-owned firms in the UK

And on hotels:

More evidence of robust Scottish economy as hotel sector outperforms UK average

Scottish hotels outperform those in rest of UK: STV report good news for Scotland’s economy but fail to understand it

Value of top Edinburgh hotels grows significantly faster than rest of Europe

Forget, GERs and GDP, Scottish hotel investment soars by 60% in one year!

Scotland’s hotels a better investment than those in England or Europe: SNP Administration works?

 

(Image: Alistair Linford)

BBC Scotland news have been making much of their recent discovery that:

‘Three Aberdeen fire engines stood down due to staffing problems’

The headline is quite dishonest and tabloid-like in its attempt to scare. In fact, one vehicle was not available last Tuesday and two were not available on Wednesday. There is a big gap between the headline and the facts here. At no time, were three vehicles unavailable. On only one day were two unavailable. On only two days in the previous three or four months (100 plus days) were any vehicles unavailable. BBC Scotland last reported problems in April 2018.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-north-east-orkney-shetland-45128404

How much of a risk is death by fire?

From the BBC:

England: The figures for July 2016 to June 2017 put the annual total at 346, which was 20% up from the previous year’s figure of 289. We do not have comparable figures for July to June in previous years.

Scotland: There were 44 fire-related casualties in Scotland in 2016-17, down [2%] from 45 the previous year.

How much are firefighter numbers falling?

Firefighter numbers in Scotland fell by 1.2% between 2016 and 2017 and by 13% from 2011.

https://www.firescotland.gov.uk/media/1184265/fs_org_statistics_2016_17_v1.0.pdf

In England:

‘If we restrict ourselves to just firefighters, there were 29,018 full-time equivalent firefighters employed directly by their fire services across England in 2010. That had fallen to 22,957 in 2017 – that’s a drop of just over 6,000.’

That’s a fall of 21%.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-42001463

Occasional shortages of firefighters are common across the UK:

Surrey firefighters ‘bailed out’ by London colleagues on another day of …

Chronic staff shortages at North Yorkshire fire control leave public …

Firefighter raises alarm over inadequate cover in Torbay – Devon Live

Struggle to fill vacancies at rural fire stations that rely on part-time …

Firefighter shortage means Norfolk crew cannot go out to emergencies …

Spire FM – News – Amesbury Fire Station tackling crew shortages

Shortage of crews at Suffolk fire station | Latest Ipswich News – Ipswich …

Fire crew shortage in Gwynedd and Anglesey ‘could be putting lives at …

North Wales fire staff shortages put lives at risk say whistleblowers …

Staff shortages at Dublin Fire Brigade trigger reduced services

Report reveals shortage of Highland firefighters – The Scotsman

Retained firefighter shortage adds up to thousands of hours …

Stockport fire station closes because of firefighter shortage …

HARTLEY WINTNEY FIRE STATION NEEDS YOU!!!!!! – Hartley Wintney …

Campaign begins for more people to become Crediton firefighters …

Orkney’s fire stations facing staff shortages – The Orcadian Online

Petworth emergencies raise fire service concerns – Midhurst and …

Newquay fire chief admits staff shortage – Telegraph

I don’t have the time or the will to check how small-scale the Aberdeen shortages were compared to any of those listed above. Perhaps BBC Scotland’s large team of research assistants might like to?

Two developments, in the last year and a half, suggest that Scotland is beginning to recover at least some of its historic metal-making capacity. In Insider today:

‘Liberty Steel Dalzell back in business. A Scottish steel plant has vowed to win back market share in the import-dominated market for heavy-duty steel that is used in bridges, buildings and battleships. Dalzell is now the only remaining UK-owned large producer of plate steel, an ultra-tough product used for demanding applications such as large physical structures, ship bodies, undersea oil pipes, bulldozers and wind towers…..the plant has just secured two substantial new contracts and is on target to produce more than 120,000 tonnes of plate this year…..this figure is set to rise by at least another 25% next year, as the plant’s expansion plan moves into its next phase. Other Liberty plants in Scotland and England will use a significant amount of steel from Dalzell to make products such as wind towers and oil pipelines.’

https://www.insider.co.uk/news/liberty-steel-dalzell-motherwell-mackay-13051829

In March 2017, I was able to write this:

The Lochaber Delivery Group met for the first time today to begin the process of helping the GFG Alliance (Liberty House and SIMEC) make the most of their total £450 million investment in the area subsequent to buying the Fort William aluminium complex and estate lands from Rio Tinto in a £330 million deal in December.

You’ll remember that Liberty House have already worked with the Scottish Government to save the steel plants at Dalzell and Clydebridge. The plans are to revitalise (already underway) the smelter to manufacture car parts, to do the same for nearby hydro plants (£120 million), to maximise cost savings in that manufacture and, along with two bio-fuel plants, to create a state-of-the-art facility which will add 1 000 direct and 1 000 indirect jobs in the area and a predicted £1 billion addition to the local economy. Unemployment in the Fort William area is generally well under (2.9%) the overall Scottish rate (4.9%) but I’m sure it would be a very popular place to relocate to.

This will be the UK’s last aluminium smelter putting it in a very good place to compete to produce car parts for the wider UK and European car manufacturers. Of course India’s car ownership growth is the fastest in the world at 7.64% or 2.54 million vehicles in 2016 and is expected to grow by 775% to 2040! Who owns the Lochaber mill? It’s a Mr Gupta. Now where does that name originate?

GFG Alliance (Liberty/SIMEC) Executive Chairman Sanjeev Gupta said:

‘One of the key reasons we invested in the Highlands was because people welcomed us here. That’s been reinforced by the positive response of the many agencies in the new Lochaber Delivery Group who are eager to play their part in delivering the goal of a clean, competitive and sustainable manufacturing sector in the Highlands.’

http://news.gov.scot/news/lochaber-once-more

http://www.livemint.com/Industry/bulpIdEod7tk9HTftdo9bL/At-764-growth-India-fastest-growing-passenger-car-market.html

http://auto.ndtv.com/news/indias-passenger-car-ownership-to-grow-775-per-cent-by-2040-study-1425954

I appreciate that this is only a fraction of what we once did but it’s still something to be encouraged by.

• I know it should be ‘mettle’, pedants. I’m playing with words for effect! Anyhoo, as recently as the 17^th Century, the words were used inter-changeably so there!

(c) Alamy Stock Photo

Increasing staff vacancies add to evidence of a robust Scottish economy and are especially good news for Scottish workers

From Insider today:

‘Permanent staff demand in Scotland grows sharply. Royal Bank of Scotland Jobs for Scotland report discovers a rise in staff vacancies alongside a shrinking candidate supply. The sharp growth in permanent staff appointments continued in July, according to the latest Royal Bank of Scotland Jobs for Scotland report.’

A sharp increase in vacancies means business is confident and growing. This is also good news for the workers, for a change:

‘Amid rising staff vacancies and shrinking candidate supply, pay pressures intensified in July. Salaries awarded to permanent starters in Scotland increased at the fastest pace in six months, with inflation outpacing that seen for the UK overall. Meanwhile, temp pay rates in Scotland rose at the sharpest degree since April 2017.’

https://www.insider.co.uk/news/royal-bank-of-scotland-jobs-13044872

So, wages are growing faster in Scotland than in the non-Scottish parts of the UK. Other evidence of strength in the Scottish economy, has been noted here earlier:

63% fall in large business insolvencies as Scottish economy reveals strength

Scottish onshore economy grows by at least double the rate of UK

See this Douglas? Business investment in Scotland up 250%!

Scottish Business Strength No.77: Small Scottish construction firms’ growth up 17%

Scottish small businesses still more confident than those in non-Scottish parts

Business activity soars to four-year high across manufacturing and service

Business confidence in Scotland soars by 24% while it sinks 29% in non-Scottish parts of UK

Scottish businesses more likely to be stable than those in rest of UK: News from a parallel universe unknown to our mainstream media

Scottish Government supports economy with new business rates unique in UK

Scottish business confidence higher than in any other region of UK

Over to you, Douglas Fraser.

https://www.isdscotland.org/Health-Topics/Waiting-Times/Publications/2018-08-07/2018-08-07-Cancellations-Summary.pdf?33071

Where operations are cancelled due to non-clinical reasons such as shortages of skilled staff or of operating theatres, this can be tremendously upsetting for patients and is a reasonable indicator of problems in the system.

You can see from the above graph that operations cancelled by the patients or for a good clinical reason are largely unchanged since June 2017. However, operations cancelled for lack of capacity or for non-clinical reasons have fallen dramatically in the last three months and, crucially, continue to fall below last year’s low point in the summer of 2017.

From the data tables (ref below), cancellations based on the capacity of hospitals or for non-clinical reasons such as staff non-availability, by hospital fell from 587 in April 2018 to 403 in June 2018. This is a fall of 31% in 3 months. I have of course used the three-month figure to get a better headline as recommended in BBC Scotland’s editorial guidelines.

https://www.isdscotland.org/Health-Topics/Waiting-Times/Publications/2018-08-07/2018-08-07-Cancellations-Summary.pdf?33071535826

 

(c) dundee labour and gizmodo

Yesterday’s BBC Scotland headline story repeated throughout the day was one version or another of:

‘Former NHS Tayside chief executive ‘received £300,000’ pay-off. NHS Tayside’s former chief executive received a final financial package of more than £300,000, an MSP has claimed. Labour MSP Jenny Marra said the “golden handshake” was a “slap in the face” for the people of Tayside.’

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-45083257

Notice the careful use of speech mark in the headline but their abandonment in the main text of the website version. The broadcast versions, of course, lacked any such subtlety and the message for viewers was bleated clearly – SNP baaaaaahhhhd!  Detecting a pattern, this tweet simplified it for us:

 

Notably, however, a senior SNP minister entered the fray, condemning the BBC in the way many of us had despaired of them doing previously:

 Jeane Freeman did not, of course, get the chance to headline her protest to a mass broadcast audience and we must hope the 600 plus retweets have pushed the message beyond SNP membership.

In the wake of the exposure of the BBC attempting to close down pro-independence Youtube sites on copyright ‘contraventions’ while ignoring the same by other sites, the above story is no surprise to most of us and follows numerous ‘fake news’ and no-news stories, just in 2018, reported here, aimed at damaging by association the Scottish Government.

IMPORTANT: Readers with health problems are advised not to look at the length of this list (43!)  before sitting down with a stiff drink.

1.      Massive Fraseresque ‘BUTLIST’ from BBC Scotland to downplay business success

2.      Update: BBC analysis wrong? Scotland’s A&E departments infinitely better than those in non-Scottish parts yet BBC Scotland pounce on stats like a starved rat

3.      Scottish prescriptions costs ‘soaring’ 0.1% above inflation warn BBC, Scotsman and iNews

4.      Is BBC Scotland exploiting patients with mental health problems to construct an ill-founded attack on NHS Tayside?

5.      BBC Scotland and BMA collude to produce a classic NHS scare story based on shoddy, unreliable, research

6.      BBC UK silent on the Tory child rapist and the Tory serial child sex offender yet Reporting Scotland offer all-day headline coverage of the SNP MSP’s inappropriate text

7.      Scottish Government announces that poverty gap is closing. BBC Scotland ignores it

8.      Retired Professor fails BBC Reporting Scotland Editor on Organised Crime research

9.      Retired Professor stumps BBC Scotland Acting Temporary Deputy Head of News, Current Affairs and Royal Babies on Obesity

10.  Racial hate crime continues to fall in Scotland as it soars in England and Wales, but BBC Scotland finds suitable distraction

11.  Top professor suggests top psychiatrist was taken advantage of by BBC Scotland’s ambulance chasers

12.  ‘Hearse-chasers?’ BBC Scotland scare ‘investigation’ finds 0.04% of dead bodies being left in hospital mortuaries

13.  How many GANGSTERS are preying on the financial fears of pensioners? BBC Scotland and Herald care not, as long as they can scare us

14.  Scottish Fire and Rescue Service making ‘steady progress’ that is ignored by BBC Scotland’s scare story

15.  More students from the most deprived parts of Scotland are entering Higher Education but, once again, BBC Scotland attempts to mislead us

16.  Off we go? Within days of Scottish independence debate restart, BBC Scotland attempt to deceive and to create fear on drug treatment figures

17.  BBC Scotland High Heidyin, Sarah Smith, ponders why a fire won’t light when she and her kind have denied it oxygen

18.  BBC Scotland lie and distort to try again to spread violent crime crisis into Scotland despite it having only 3.5% of the gangs for 8% of the population, falling levels of violent crime and because of falling levels of fear of crime?

19.  BBC Scotland hiding Britain’s exploitation of Scotland. EU Money specifically for Scottish hill farmers given to English farmers?

20.  Scottish Government makes 200 European links in effort to counter damage from Tory hard Brexit. BBC Scotland says: ‘eh, what, when?’

21.  BBC Scotland News misuses research findings to lie and scare about drug use in Scotland

22.  BBC Scotland News and Print Journalism on Scottish policing: ‘Forces’ in crisis?

23.  Despite SNP, Labour and Tories (!) getting together to fully fund huge expansion of early learning and childcare, BBC Scotland try to deny all of it with out-of-date comment

24.  BBC Scotland and Herald warn that paediatricians can’t carry on despite 64% increase in paediatric specialists under SNP administration and 8.7% fall in the birth rate.

25.  £13.8 million in support for bereaved families from……? BBC Scotland, who is it from? Could it be from the Scottish Government? Don’t want to say?

26.  The Power of Early Morning Nightmares: Waking up to BBC Scotland and learning to fear an independent future: 18th April 2018

27.  BBC Scotland talks-down the Scottish economy: Bias by omission, language choices and a Rev IM Jolly delivery

28.  Scottish Chambers of Commerce describe First Minister’s trip to China as ‘successful’. BBC Scotland polish their bias-by-omission skills.

29.  How BBC’s Douglas Fraser manages to talk down Scotland’s economy using out-of-date facts and past-it thinking

30.  There are 12% more health visitors, in one year, in Scotland! Will somebody tell BBC Scotland, the Scotsman and the Herald?

31.  BBC News tries to spread knife crime crisis into Scotland to tell us: ‘You’re no different. Don’t get any ideas!’

32.  Lib Dems, Tories and Labour take turns to help Scotsman, STV and BBC Scotland cast unjustified doubt on successes of Police Scotland, as crime plummets regardless

33.  SNP administration doesn’t rest on earlier success of child health strategies but BBC Scotland try to give credit to Labour.

34.  As hate crime falls in Scotland and soars elsewhere, STV and BBC Scotland report fake news of an increase

35.  BBC Scotland website gets it right once more after Jackie bird deliberately gets it wrong, as usual.

36.  BBC Scotland uses a handful of anecdotes from only three customers to suggest ScotRail has serious problems that are not evident from proper research

37.  As NHS staffing climbs, Labour co-ordinate anti-SNP propaganda in Herald, Scotsman, BBC and STV on nursing and midwifery staffing

38.  BBC Scotland’s wilful mis-represenation on literacy levels

39.  BBC Scotland’s shameless attempt to scare with claim that Scottish hospital has cladding ‘similar’ to that of Grenfell revealing ignorance of Scottish building regulations.

40.  BBC Scotland and STV News attempt to mislead us on Higher Education application rates from ‘poorest areas’ and former mathematics teacher Iain Gray fails to add them up properly for them.

41.  How to make a ‘potentially massive’ oil find one that ‘isn’t a big find’? Just lie, omit and minimise. Ask BBC Scotland.

42.  Scottish Government pledges £60 million to maintain its confirmed UK and European lead in low-carbon innovation but BBC Scotland News reports unsubstantiated rumours that ‘Budget cuts ‘could damage Scotland’s climate change ambitions’’

43.  ‘Ambulance-chasers’* BBC Scotland digs up fake news as Scotland’s ambulance services disappoint them by coping well with the winter surge in demand

I’ll stop there in January 2018.

 

I’ve got a sair heid from reading this.

Here is McNab’s opening statement:

‘More than £400million of spending has been axed from Scotland’s education system since the start of the decade, official figures have revealed.  Older pupils have suffered the brunt of the cuts with spending on secondary education falling by about £350m from budgets since 2010.Nurseries and primary schools saw a rise in spending, according to the figures from the independent Scottish Parliament Information Centre (SPICe). Recent years have seen a worrying fall in Scottish education in international league tables and the SNP Government is now facing claims that it has failed to protect schools from the worst impact of Tory austerity.’

https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/spending-on-scots-schools-falls-by-400m-in-a-decade-1-4779195

It’s a chaotic piece of writing, peppered with daft comments including that by Iain Grey, but I’ll concentrate on dealing with the two main issues –  a fall in Secondary school spending, leading supposedly but with no evidence at all of it, to older pupils ‘feeling the brunt’  and to an implied connection to a fall in performance in international league tables.

Spending fall in Secondary schools not properly explained

McNab entirely misses these crucial figures:

In 2007 there were 798 275 pupils overall and 309 560 in secondary schools. In 2017 there were 688 959 pupils overall and 281 933 in secondary schools.

https://www.gov.scot/Topics/Statistics/Browse/School-Education/Datasets

So, there was a 15.8%drop in the overall number of pupils and a 9.7% drop in the number of secondary pupils over the last ten years.  McNab doesn’t tell us what the percentage change in budgets was for the same period and he doesn’t source anything, so I can’t trace it quickly. I guess, someone mentioned inflation and he decided not to bother with all that. He does later tell us this:

‘Secondary spending has fallen from £2.25bn to £1.9 bn last year. Primary schooling has risen slightly to £1.96bn, but now tops secondary spending. Nursery spending has also seen a slight increase by more than £50m to reach £410m.’

That suggests a fall of £.35 billion or £350 million from £2.25 billion in 2007 which is a 15% fall. That’s about the same as the overall percentage fall in pupil numbers but greater than the fall in secondary numbers. I’m sure secondary staff might complain at that, but does it not simply reflect a shift in resourcing from secondary to the historically less well funded primary and pre-school sectors, in line with both explicit policy, the research suggesting the shift was needed, and mentioned by McNab in his opening statements?

Do International league tables tell us anything valuable?

I’ve written about this before and the simple answer is that they are useless. Reading them, the Unionist media and the opposition parties scream out ‘crisis’ and reveal just how little they know about education, especially international comparisons. Here is the truth of the matter in ten statements which I elaborated on at the link below:

1. Some tests just suit some countries’ education systems. Doing well in one test doesn’t make that country’s overall education system better than that of lower rankers and in some cases, especially in East Asia (China, Korea, Singapore), it is evidence of them being worse in many ways.
2. The PISA results are based on unreliable estimates with huge scope for error and thus, I quote, ‘useless.’
3. Summarising a country’s education system in just three numbers is, I quote, ‘madness.’
4. Comparing countries with radically different cultures and educational structures is meaningless.
5. PISA does not measure curriculum knowledge just general skills, so the so-called successes of Finland and South Korea or the middle-rank ‘failure’ of Scotland are not based on the quality of their teachers, their schools or their curriculum.
6. The Finnish system is not that successful in other ways that PISA does not test.
7. The highly authoritarian, ‘industrial’ East Asian systems are a form of child abuse we surely do not want to see in Scotland.
8. The East Asian systems are not at all successful in developing the creativity, originality and innovation needed for future success in developed societies.
9. The East Asian systems, in most cases, brutally abandon children with learning difficulties.
10. The Scottish system is highly successful in feeding its universities with ever more and better qualified students, it is inclusive, caring and explicitly promotes creativity, originality and innovation.

Scotland’s school’s PISA results ‘lean’ toward nothing meaningful. Finland’s success is not real. South Korea and China’s educational programmes amount to child abuse