Lib Dems, Tories and Labour take turns to help Scotsman, STV and BBC Scotland cast unjustified doubt on successes of Police Scotland, as crime plummets regardless


The Scotsman, building their piece around Lib Dem MSP Liam McArthur, wrote with wrong-headed hyperbole set to stun:

‘MSP urges independent review of crisis-hit police: Police Scotland today faces calls for an independent review into its operation in order to trigger an “honest conversation” about where it has gone wrong over the last five years. For five stormy years, Police Scotland has been mired in controversies that have seen the departure of two chief constables, rows over police accountability and concern over operational policing.’

Informed by Tory MSP, Margaret Mitchell, BBC Scotland wrote:

‘Police Scotland in particular has faced criticism over a number of issues. The service is currently looking for its third chief, while the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) – one of several bodies created by the legislation – is on its third chief and third chairperson.’

STV News added Scottish Labour justice spokesman Daniel Johnson who said:

‘The committee must assess how this turmoil has affected policing and public safety.The SNP Government must acknowledge these issues and their own mistakes to improve Police Scotland over the next five years, rather than the same old intransigence they have shown over the past five years.’

STV, to be fair, did insert this telling little snippet at the end:

‘Despite criticism, national statistics published this week show crime in Scotland has fallen by around a third and 58% of respondents said police were doing a good or excellent job.’

The above comment only in the STV report reminds us of the key indicator of success by any police force – levels of crime.

I’m not saying the cases of spying and the instability in the top post don’t matter but they and the cases of failure, in two specific cases, matter much less than the overall performance of the force as evidenced in crime levels experienced across millions of citizens. Looking at the graph, above, we see crime continue to fall fast after the creation of Police Scotland. This is not evidence of a ‘crisis-hit’ service, or of ‘stormy years’ or of ‘turmoil’.

If crime continues to fall fast, most of us are satisfied and all we see wrong is a change in leadership and two sad but rare failures, then Police Scotland is a success.


5 thoughts on “Lib Dems, Tories and Labour take turns to help Scotsman, STV and BBC Scotland cast unjustified doubt on successes of Police Scotland, as crime plummets regardless

  1. Alasdair Macdonald. April 1, 2018 / 3:13 pm

    To be fair to Ms Margaret Mitchell MSP, when interviewed on GMS, she made no derogatory comments about Police Scotland. As chair of the relevant committee at Holyrood she said that now that Police Scotland had been in existence for five years it was appropriate for a Parliamentary Committee to look, objectively, at how this significant piece of legislation has turned out in practice.

    This is an important job of Parliamentary Committees and gives MSPs the opportunity to be clear-headedly deliberative in the public interest – as many of them can be – rather than indulging in the shabby the ping-pong of petty points scoring.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Alasdair Macdonald. April 1, 2018 / 10:00 pm

    Did you see the report that London has overtaken New York City in terms of the number of murders. I do not have the population figures for both cities to be able to calculate a rate per 100 000 people. I think NYC has a greater population and so the rate for London is likely to be greater.

    Sadly, the data for London includes a very high level of knife murders.

    Liked by 2 people

    • johnrobertson834 April 2, 2018 / 7:39 am

      I did. I took the rate to mean per capita but maybe I’m giving the journos to much credit for stats awareness?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s