(c) common space and pinsdaddy
07.22am today and those are the opening lines of the only reader comment under an article by Kevin McKenna. The headline is:
‘Scottish NHS is facing a crisis that affects us all’
The long rambling piece is full both of ‘respect’ for the First Minister and recognition of the SNP’s good health. Kevin is, of course, after a dramatic conversion on some quiet, no witnesses, ‘road to Damascus’, a confirmed supporter of independence. Kevin is also a confirmed and active critic of the SNP and a champion of Roman Catholicism. I know, he’s entitled to criticise the SNP. I criticised Nicola’s very odd (naïve?) support for the war criminal Hilary Clinton and her recommendation that we read the work of the war criminal, Henry Kissinger, but I know that only the SNP have the muscle and the drive to push this thing through with the rest of the movement providing the ideas, the songs, the noise and the drama.
Kevin spends much of his time criticising SNP polices such as the named person thing and, mostly commonly, whinging, evidence-free, about the NHS in Scotland. Coincidentally, it’s the same target that BBC Scotland have clearly identified as the one they can most effectively scare the elderly and the infirm with, thus bolstering the anxious No vote. He protests his love for the idea of independence but spends little time working directly to undermine its enemies.
He reminds me of a Rangers supporter who insists he’s now for independence but, when pressed, says that that hope has to come second to Rangers winning the league again! What would Kevin take before Scottish independence? I’m guessing but, would a counter-reformation be nice?
Might the list of preferences be, actually, infinitely long because Kevin is a fake supporter? I’m not saying he is an actual ‘mole’, ‘run’ and funded by MI5 (or is it 6 because we’re still ‘foreign’?), but I am saying that his writing, like some others on the ‘critical’ wing of the Yes movement, has the undermining effect of a mole. Maybe he’s a ‘blind mole’? The floating Yes/No voter is unlikely to be affected by too obvious, exaggerated and direct attacks on the SNP but more subtle pieces, equally wrong and usually free of evidence, and, crucially, laced with wee bits of praise for Nicola’s maturity, for the SNP’s strength or for the vague nobility of the cause, will be insidious and more effective, like all good propaganda.
What is Kevin’s agenda? I think he wants a good income from his writing, special treatment for Catholicism and a more caring sort of social democratic society. On a purely pragmatic basis he now thinks independence might be his best bet for that but, if Labour look like returning to power in Westminster, watch him.
Oh, yes NHS Scotland. Here’s some of the evidence, just that going back to March 2018, which, Kevin didn’t use:
NHS Scotland survives summer heatwave despite SNP failure to control London Met Office
SNP Government acts early to prevent NHS winter crisis in 2018/19
Six consecutive years of NHS Scotland staffing growth
91% satisfaction with NHS Scotland staff! Patients even more satisfied than before
NHS Scotland sees more patients within 18 weeks as demand soars
At 78% level of satisfaction with NHS Scotland is impressive 36% higher than for the NHS across UK
NHS Scotland first to be 100% Baby Friendly
Updated: The Scotsman colludes with Labour and Tories to fake another crisis in NHS Scotland
NHS Lothian ‘bed-blocking’ remains much lower than average in NHS England
National auditors find two very different NHS systems in the UK. Someone tell Theresa today.
Agree John , he is a Labourite , any excuse to knock the SNP government . He should take a cold hard look at his Unionist pals in England and Wales before demonising the SNHS !.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Let’s see who is first to his turn back the Union?
LikeLiked by 1 person
McKenna is, in my opinion, a false flag journalist, pretending to be pro independence.
Why would this be? In the absence of genuine independence journalists in our media, then people like McKenna can make a descent living being used to “balance” a tv show/newspaper.
Read his articles, listen to his comments—is he genuine? I don’t think so!
LikeLiked by 3 people
My view exactly.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I agree, but let me assure you, Kevin McKenna is no champion of Catholicism and is certainly not regarded as such within the Catholic Church in Scotland. And as for his wish for special treatment for Catholicism, if he does harbour such a thought then he is the only one. Fair and equal treatment however is another matter.
LikeLiked by 2 people
See this:
Scottish Catholic Observer
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Notable former reporters include SNP MP Brendan O’Hara,[7] war correspondent Francis McCullagh,[8] and Kevin McKenna, columnist for The Observer and former deputy editor of The Herald and executive editor of the Daily Mail in Scotland.[9]
Same man?
LikeLiked by 1 person
And this:
http://www.sconews.co.uk/opinion/24718/are-we-protecting-catholic-education/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Please John, take the word of another journalist. Kevin McKenna is now, and always has been, a self-serving erse. He is the journalistic equivalent of his mate Jim Murphy. And likening this scion of the posh seats at Celtic Park to a Rangers fan will win you no prizes with him.
LikeLiked by 3 people
My view exactly.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Never trusted McKenna. Like him I was raised Catholic but I don’t see religion having anything to do with Scotland’s, or my, future and I suspect when push comes to shove McKenna will use some faux anti-Catholicism to stop him voting YES. Religion – Scotland’s curse!!!
LikeLiked by 3 people
What Mr McKenna is forgetting is the falling levels of church attendance, and the shrinking levels of children at RC schools. It’s happening all over and not because anyone has a mysterious plan to do down the Catholics.
I am a non-practicing RC now and have countless friends who have regretfully turned their backs due to child abuse cases in particular. Hard to reconcile ‘insider’ knowledge by those who should have known better and stand before you pontificating…
Kevin is going to continue playing this ‘I will’, ‘I am’, ‘I maybe’ game until his outlet is no longer there, or retirement, whichever comes first. Cynical? Moi? 😀
LikeLiked by 2 people
Kevin McKenna’s column in The National is consistently un-read by me. I think he is entirely entangled with the Ian McWhirter/ Henry McLeish style of uncertain supporters.
LikeLiked by 6 people