Alex Cole-Hamilton tries to pressurise Scottish Government with old, ‘English’, whingedata

 (Photo by Ken Jack/Getty Images)

Last Thursday Cole-Hamilton asked:

https://www.parliament.scot/S5ChamberOffice/WA20190620.pdf

Though Cole-Hamilton appears to have read the above 76% figure in the 2019, From the Frontline, report, it is referring to the 2017, Destination GP, report which contains the actual results from the RCGP research into attitudes. The 2017 survey findings are based on only 9.4% of the 3 680 students in 30 UK medical schools from May to July 2017. Not only is this a small sample, it is a self-selecting sample, biased toward those holding a negative viewpoint, but it is also a UK-wide survey with no Scottish breakdown and thus not a valid indicator of morale amongst Scottish students.

file:///D:/Users/John/Downloads/RCGP-destination-GP-nov-2017.pdf

file:///D:/Users/John/Downloads/RCGP-scotland-frontline-june-2019%20(3).pdf

Given the numerous indicators that GP practice in Scotland is a considerably preferable experience to that in parts of England, it seems unlikely the results would be similar here. For evidence see:

Why did BBC Breakfast pretend GP staffing figures for Scotland are not available?

Big increase in number of women GPs is excellent news for Scotland

No GP Crisis in Scotland but..

Report of GP staffing crisis in England appears before Scottish media can fake equivalent story

Scottish GP vacancy rate now only one -third of that in non-Scottish parts of UK

In the Scotsman today, 93% of Scottish patients get appointment with GP within 2 days!

Lib Dems feed STV with dubious tale of GPs working too many hours

Scottish GP Contract rated ‘far superior’ by BMA, introduced today, to strengthen patient care

 

2 thoughts on “Alex Cole-Hamilton tries to pressurise Scottish Government with old, ‘English’, whingedata

  1. William Henderson June 24, 2019 / 8:24 pm

    I suppose it’s tempting to just shake your head at the sheer inanity of the many questions thrown at the Scottish Government day in and day out. This one is just a recent example of the trend. However, has it struck the likes of A C-H that the contrast of the usual high-quality answers to the poor-quality questions is always in full view to anyone paying attention.

    Have the ‘opposition’ in the Scottish Parliament fallen into a way of thinking that makes it ok for a politician not of the party in power to ignore the need to think of policies alternative to those being followed at any given time? Do they, indeed, know what it is to have policies which justify the title of ‘politician’, or do they believe in their hearts that carping from the sidelines without a care for responsibility is endearing them to their constituents and justifying their very high pay? Is it, perhaps, just part of their perception of their function that they become nauseating human beings?

    Just asking…..

    Liked by 3 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s