Empress Ruth has no policies, but all at the BBC worship her empty charms


Ruth Davidson’s return to politics today saw her on both Reporting Scotland and the main news where they’d all really prefer to be.

We heard again that she doesn’t want to be prime minister. Is there any evidence that anyone outside of their media bubble seriously think she could or should be? She has never won a first-past-the-post election, her branch of the party has never proposed a policy that has been adopted in at least ten years and she looks like presiding over terminal decline as the SNP swallows Labour and Brexit/UKIP bite her party in half. By all objective measures she has nothing beyond some alleged cheeky charm, and the pretend confidence of a third-team scrum-half.

I know why they like her, though. She seems to prefer the status quo with none of the unsettling changes offered by Corbyn/Leonard, by Farage/Johnson or, of course, by the SNP. The senior staff at the BBC long for a pre-Iraq Blairite Britain where you can pretend to care about the poor, even a do a wee bit for them, as long as you and your offspring can continue to benefit from the pretend meritocracy, where you can keep your pay differentials, where you can enjoy being part of sophisticated European culture and where you can hope for promotion to places where you might report on Britain as it projects itself globally. You might go to New York, Moscow, Paris or Beijing. You might even interview, and be seen doing so, the premiers of the leading powers. When you read politics at Glasgow, Edinburgh or Saint Andrews, you didn’t dream of reporting on farming subsidies in the Western Isles.

So, on BBC 1 News, we had a full two-minute interview with Scottish Labour-appointee, Sarah Smith, where Ruth was able to say with regard to a second independence referendum:

‘I’m saying that I’ll say no.’

Surely any half-baked interviewer might ask why she feels she is in a position to ‘say no’, as a leader of an unpopular minority party and why he has changed her mind (above).

Then Sarah tells us:

‘Ruth Davidson is often talked about as a future UK conservative party leader even prime minister’

This line keeps being repeated but only by journalists repeating what other journalists are saying based on the kind of sentiments discussed above. It’s just rubbish. When Ruth modestly declines, you’re left to wonder why on earth is that news and even news that has jumped out of the place where we live into the Big World of Westminster?

Perhaps most obviously absent was the returning leader of the Scottish Conservatives not being asked how she might react to the current existential threats being posed to them, in evidence from several polls, suggesting an SNP surge and clear inroads being made into their support even in Scotland by Brexit/UKIP.

On Reporting Scotland, Ruth was, surprise, surprise, the headline act, denying us a referendum again but best of all, we heard:

‘She intends to replace Ms Surgeon as First Minister at the elections in 2021.’

Good grief! The most recent YouGov full poll puts the SNP 23 points ahead with more than double the support of the Conservatives! Will anyone mention this? If it was reversed and they were interviewing Sturgeon, would they take off the gloves? Will they ask her about membership or the likely attendance at the forthcoming conference? No of course not. Don’t be daft.

Then when Brian does ask if Brexit has changed everything, with regard to second independence referendum, she ignores the question. He just lets it go.

Finally, Brian returns to the story that some Tories still hanker for Ruth to choose Westminster over Holyrood. Who are these people? I’ve never heard anyone, of any significance, say that.



11 thoughts on “Empress Ruth has no policies, but all at the BBC worship her empty charms

  1. Ramsay Millar April 29, 2019 / 9:13 pm

    Great analysis of where we really are politically in Scotland.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Alasdair Macdonald April 29, 2019 / 9:31 pm

    They like her because she was once one of them at the BBC. And, they like her because Scottish Labour has sunk into terminal mediocrity after a succession of nonentity leaders – Iain Gray, Johan Lamont, Jim Murphy, Kezia Dugdale and Richard Leonard, with, for good measure, Jackie Baillie as a brief interim leader and LibDems have Wullie Wombat. Since the BBC default is hostility to the nationalists/separatists/thae basturts, and the field is so bereft, The Colonel is the only one who appears plausibly human. Many Scottish Labour voters would love her to be their leader, which is why they are shifting to her, because she has made ‘The Union’ her cause.She will face no searching questions from the BBC.

    Contrast that with the hissing, spitting rancorous spleen which Hayley Miller shows every time she interviews – sorry, persistently and sneeringly interrupts – and SNP politician.

    PS I see Kezia has been offered a nice ‘billet’ at the John Smith institute at Glasgow University, run by the sister of The Colonel’s ‘interlocutor’, Ms Sarah Smith. The Vice Principal expects her to turn it into an internationally recognised powerhouse!

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Donald McGregor April 29, 2019 / 9:51 pm

    Oh I am so pleased to have my jaundiced/realistic views on stuff echoed here.

    I don’t really possess the non- judgemental words required to open my nearest and dearests eyes to the crap that is ‘Mainstream Media’ but I’m so glad you do, sir.

    But, do you know, in 2014 we nearly nearly tipped the balance of belief, and once we can do that there’s a good chance at making it home!
    So please do keep it up

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Legerwood April 29, 2019 / 10:04 pm

    “”She has never won a first-past-the-post election, …””

    I think she has. Is she not the constituency MSP for Edinburgh Central? Constituency MSPs are elected by a FPTP system.

    She did start out as a list MSP though

    Liked by 1 person

    • Andy P April 29, 2019 / 10:09 pm

      Correct. That’s why Joanna Cherry or Angus Robertson are tipped to stand against her at the next SP elections.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Donald McGregor April 29, 2019 / 10:35 pm

      I think you are correct – but I suspect John was meaning ‘won’ as in the wider party election sense rather than individual seat.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Derek Cameron April 30, 2019 / 5:19 am

    The puffery surrounding the one trick pony that is Ruth Davidson shames so called journalists. These types used in the old days to be called ” fans with typewriters “.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Ludo Thierry April 30, 2019 / 7:44 am

    Further bit of good news from Spain and Catalonia this morning (following the encouraging Spanish Parlt. election results). Suspect the news will have El Coronel Ruthie greetin’ into her coffee this morn. Link and snippet below:


    SPANISH Supreme Court Judge Pablo Llarena has withdrawn European and international arrest warrants for all the exiled Catalan politicians including former president Carles Puigdemont.

    The move will affect outstanding cases against Clara Ponsati in Scotland, along with Toni Comín, Meritxell Serret, Lluis Puig and Marta Rovira.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s