Criminal Proceedings in Scotland, 2017-18: A tale of enviable good news concealed by BBC Scotland



Criminal Proceedings in Scotland, 2017-18, contains several pieces of evidence suggesting progress in Scotland which Humza Yousaf’s equivalents in the non-Scottish parts of the UK would sell their grannies for, yet ignoring the above dramatic good news and many other trends reported below, Reporting Scotland found a way to extract and construct a bad news story out of this extensive report:

Yesterday, Jackie Bird told us:

‘Almost 80% of people jailed in Scotland received sentences of less than a year according to new figures. That’s despite government plans to ask courts not to impose such short prison terms and instead use community sentences such as unpaid work.’

You see how they did this. They decided that all sentences up to 12 months, rather than those up to 3 months were ‘short sentences’, found less progress there and snuffled out this wee truffle they could selectively foreground:


Of course, we cannot see what proportion of those sentences were in the 6 to 12-month range. Do we actually want those reduced? Are they short sentences at all? Not to my mind, they’re not.

The report is 106 pages long and stuffed with other headline-worthy news, all ignored. Here’s my extract:

Handling offensive weapons:


Oh how, the ministers in London, England and Wales would drool over the above. Of course, RS would feel able to just report the last year and ignore the unwanted trend. You’ll remember many other times when they have preferred the longer view just to get a bigger headline percentage.

Overall convictions trend, still ongoing:


Convictions for crime continued to fall steady in the years since the SNP came to power. Multiple factors will be contributory, but the government of the day and its policies must take some of the credit just as, surely, they’d take any blame.

Average length of sentences:


The average length of sentences goes up and this is good news because it means fewer and fewer are going to prison for minor offences especially where violence is not involved. The average is now based on a smaller number serving longer terms thus increasing it. This trend shows the Scottish system encouraged by the Scottish Government has learned the key lesson that very short sentences are both ineffective and often make things worse by exposing minor offenders to the malign influence of those who have committed more serious crimes.

Fewer younger people convicted:


Though convictions for all groups have declined over the last ten years, the decrease has been most dramatic for the youngest group (under 21) and, less so, for the second youngest group (21-30). This is, of course, particularly good news as these are the groups most likely to be involved in crime. Similarly, the rate for males has declined dramatically from 46 per 1 000 population in 2008 to 28 in 2017-18. The rate for females has declined from 8 per 1 000 population in 2008 to 6 in 2017.

Spread the real news!


6 thoughts on “Criminal Proceedings in Scotland, 2017-18: A tale of enviable good news concealed by BBC Scotland

  1. Contrary January 30, 2019 / 8:55 am

    GMS radio Scotland concentrated on the youth crime rate – it is a global trend (you are not special Scotland so don’t get ideas above your station), then focuses on sentencing length, as you say here, where someone was on saying we should be doing better, because whatever Scotland does is NEVER going to be good enough. (And the far more exciting news of the first female knight, hooray for empire!)

    On that vein, I was hoping for another pigeon poo article, but I guess we’ve milked that one eh, as I can confirm that the BBC has done the damage they desired – colleagues about to venture forth into the great outdoors yesterday, make a joke about watching out for pigeon poo – I enlightened them as to the lack of real news in this story fairly strongly, but they ardently insisted on not listening and proclaiming the new southern general (no one can remember it’s actual name) to be a waste of money and a disgusting cesspit. Sigh. (In case anyone is wondering, no I don’t make many friend at work 😀 )

    Liked by 5 people

    • Alasdair Macdonald January 30, 2019 / 9:54 am

      Are the same people who poo-poo (sorry!) the QEUH going to refuse to go there if they need A&E or other treatment?

      Liked by 2 people

  2. diabloandco January 31, 2019 / 8:21 am

    I look forward to the Herald, the Daily Record , the Scotsman et al giving the punters this in depth ,good news report – only kidding.

    I look forward on a daily basis for news of the doors clanging shut on the Herald , the Daily Record , the Scotsman et al.

    As for the hideous broadcast media which has the cheek to include Scotland/ Scottish in their titles………….


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s