Has the Second Scottish Enlightenment begun?


Before I’m accused of over-stating things with the above headline claim, let me dig myself an even bigger hole – the first Scottish Enlightenment wasn’t that great anyway. We had lots of nice books and stimulating chats in Edinburgh hostelries but for the mass of Scots, only grinding poverty, clearance from the land, death and mutilation in imperial wars, disease and political powerlessness. The last ten years, I’d say, have seen many small changes combining to make things better for many of us, materially and emotionally. So….

As England’s poor, disabled and sick, twist in the wind of the former home secretary’s hostile environment and its storm of welfare and policing cuts, something is happening in Scotland even though we can step only partly out of her deadly embrace.

This isn’t an analytical treatise arguing for Scotland seeming to be becoming a better country. It’s a gentle shower of data which I think collects in the mind to suggest that something is happening here which we can begin to celebrate.

The causes will be, of course, ahem, multifactorial. While more humane, health as opposed to crime-focused, policies must take credit, many other factors will have played a part. In particular, with regard to falling crime, the distracting effect of home-based, interactive media has surely taken younger people ‘off the streets’ reducing the opportunities and motivations for crime. More controversially, the longer-term impact of the reduction of lead pollution in the environment has been associated with falling crime.

So, here are the data. Just look at them and let them form a shape as they will in your mind. There are 1 959 posts in this blog so if you need more, try searching for whatever topic interests you.

diasbledabuseeng disabledabusescot

disable rights

scotcarersallowancedisabled care.png













poverty graph





6 thoughts on “Has the Second Scottish Enlightenment begun?

  1. Stuart Mcnicoll November 30, 2018 / 8:50 am

    Brilliant as usual. I was feeling good anyway but I’ll come back to this if my mood changes, cheers.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. gavin November 30, 2018 / 1:42 pm

    Truly great stuff, John. Make us proud of the Scottish direction of travel, a wee antidote to the BEEBs endless negativity.

    And showing our national flag. The Saltire is one of the oldest national flags in Europe. Then you read about someone called Pamela S Nash whining about Scots “hijacking” their own flag.
    Thing is: historically, her brand of Anglo-British nationalism did not want the Saltire used for any function. Did not want it to fly from public buildings, and if it had to, it should be LOWER than the Union flag. British Nats stick the Union flag on every commodity they can, the BEEB is awash with it and the PM has two Union flags level with her lugs, everywhere she goes. We don’t, and shouldn’t, whine about that, so why can they not give Scots a wee bit of respect for OUR symbols.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Brian McGowan November 30, 2018 / 4:41 pm

    Thanks for this.
    I once worked with a guy who, when feeling down, would watch Rab C Nesbitt videos to lighten his mood, Posts like this are much better.
    (Better than Rab C Nesbitt shock)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s