Recognised: Scottish Government’s fight to stop life here becoming like Esther’s England



‘The experience of the United Kingdom, especially since 2010, underscores the conclusion that poverty is a political choice. Austerity could easily have spared the poor, if the political will had existed to do so. Resources were available to the Treasury at the last budget that could have transformed the situation of millions of people living in poverty, but the political choice was made to fund tax cuts for the wealthy instead.’

The report ‘Statement on Visit to the United Kingdom’, by Professor Philip Alston, United Nations Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, was published yesterday (16th). Esther McVey, the DWP Secretary of State responsible for delivering Universal Credit, resigned apparently, but conveniently, over Brexit. As the above quote suggests the report is a withering condemnation of Tory austerity policies.

The report, however, draws attention to the efforts of the SNP administration in Scotland to moderate where it can the worst of the austerity imposed. Briefly, before describing that, a few words on McVey, responsible for much of the recent suffering and child of Thatcherism.

McVey is a schoolfriend of Kate McCann and was on the board of Madeleine’s Fund before leaving for unexplained reasons. She may still be on the Samaritan’s board! Allegedly, she has been on the board of Loyal Scots, a fundraising company registered in Denmark. You can guess their purpose from the name. DWP, DUP? Finally, she claimed that the DWP policy known as the ‘rape clause’ (Is it a DUP policy too?), which forces women who have been raped to provide details of their experience in order to claim benefits for a third child, was providing therapy for rape victims by offering them “an opportunity to talk”.

Here are the extracts from the report referring to Scotland:

  • Scotland has repeatedly urged the Government to halt the rollout and paid DWP for the introduction of certain flexibilities for claimants, such as the ability to receive payments more frequently.
  • Scotland has the lowest poverty rates in the United Kingdom: Joseph Rowntree Foundation, “Poverty levels and trends in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland,”
  • However, Scotland has recently put in place schemes for addressing poverty, including its Fairer Scotland Action Plan and Tackling Child Poverty Delivery Plan. It has also used newly devolved powers to establish a promising social security system guided by the principles of dignity and social security as a human right and co-designed on the basis of evidence. The system eschews sanctions entirely and, in contrast to Universal Credit, is decidedly not digital by default. Rather, the stated goal it to make benefits equally accessible however people want to access them.

These are limited steps of course but they are not limited by desire or by will. They are limited by Westminster’s control.


7 thoughts on “Recognised: Scottish Government’s fight to stop life here becoming like Esther’s England

  1. Marconatrix November 17, 2018 / 5:28 pm

    This is how bad it’s getting in England … thank heaven for the SNP!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Alasdair Macdonald November 17, 2018 / 7:36 pm

    Channel 4 News did a big feature on this on Friday evening, but, there was only perfunctory coverage on other broadcast media. Essentially, they drummed it out with brexit rebellions and the ‘who-he?’ new Brexit minister. The covered the reappointment of Ms Amber Rudd – who, of course, will be responsible for things like this – but, there was barely a squeak. The Rapporteur’s findings were dismissed as ‘he is not using the same measures of poverty as the UK does. Ergo, it is not worth bothering about.

    Isabel Fraser mentioned it on GMS on Saturday, but it did not go very far. PVerty? – BO-RING!!!

    Liked by 2 people

    • johnrobertson834 November 18, 2018 / 5:59 am

      As seems this to be to TUS readers – less than 200 compared with average of c 1 000 and up to 5-10 000


  3. Ludo Thierry November 19, 2018 / 5:48 pm

    Hi John – You are in excellent company with the ‘theme’ of this article. The differentiated position of Scotland and the SNP Scottish Govt identified by the UN Rapporteur was also picked up by Prof. Richard Murphy @ Tax Research UK site and by the By-Line investigations site – both links (to short pieces) below. TUS keeping its finger on the pulse of the progressive zeitgeist as ever.

    It is a truly incredible situation where onlookers can observe the arrival of Amber Rudd in the DWP and heave a genuine sigh of relief that Amber Rudd (yes – Amber Rudd of ‘Windyrush’ hostile environment infamy) has been drafted in to replace Esther McVey. Really is getting to be time when Scotland presses that handy ‘ejector button’ called Indy which we have kept for just these types of ’emergencies’.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Robert Innes November 20, 2018 / 8:35 am

    Hi John,

    I first heard of this Report through your website and it makes truly appalling reading. Well done John for highlighting it. There are fewer and fewer reasons left for being a proud Brit. and this is surely, contributes to that. Utterly, utterly disgraceful.


    Robert I


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s