Herald headline distorts their own report to suggest that it should have read ‘No leading academic questions Scotland’s flagship free education policy’

0866d794-5699-4e8e-b7ad-c80264dae2c6

NOTE: principals and senior academics are not necessarily ‘leading academics’. They are more educational managers motivated by income and the consequent increase in their salaries and bonuses. Leading academics are generally professors or the like who have done research into education.

Neil Mackay, ‘Writer at large’ may not have written the headline. Indeed, it would be odd if he had. When you read on, you get a very different picture. I’ll leave the ‘Writer at large’ moniker for you to wonder at. Casual? Temporary? Retired?

All we get for tuition fees are these anonymous quotes:

  • Some of Scotland’s most senior academics are questioning the ‘sustainability’ of the SNP’s flagship policy of free education for the nation’s university students.’
  • A series of leading voices raised concerns about the policy which sees Scottish students attend university without paying tuition fees as their counterparts do in the rest of the UK.
  • One senior academic, who is part of the executive team of one of the nation’s leading universities, described the policy as a ‘prop for the middle classes..’.
  • The principal of another leading university, speaking on condition of anonymity, said: “The current funding model is unsustainable if we are going to get the level of investment we need to compete…’

Leading academics, if they really are leading academics in any sense, would surely have had the guts to be named.

After these four ‘sources’, maybe, possibly reliable, we get some named individuals who do have the courage to be named:

  • Peter Mathieson, principal of Edinburgh University: ‘[I]f there had been ‘tuition fees in my day then I think it less likely I would have gone to university’.
  • Mathieson said he did not want the fear of debt to deter students from higher education…. “When I was a school leaver my ability to tolerate debt was very limited, the reality for a lot of school leavers now is that if they are going to go to university they need to be able to tolerate debt..”
  • Jim McDonald, principal of Strathclyde University, making no plea for tuition fees at all said: “This means in order to attract and retain the best academic talent and best students from home and abroad, we need to make sure that higher education is properly funded.”
  • Anton Muscatelli, principal of Glasgow University, said he supports the current policy by the Scottish government. Muscatelli said tuition fees are a ‘societal choice. “What we see is that in developed countries, some chose to keep education free – like Scotland, Germany and Scandinavia.
  • Mary Senior, the University and College’s Union Scottish official, said Scotland should not go down the same route as England when it came to tuition fees, and added that the effective cap on Scottish students was a “pressure that needed to be addressed”.

https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/16881786.leading-academics-question-scotlands-So that’s four named ‘prominent’ flagship-free-education-policy/

So that’s four named ‘prominent’ academics, at the very least, not questioning the policy of free tuition and some alleged sources who clearly feel so strongly about charging tuition fees that they won’t be quoted.

At least my former Principal, Craig Mahoney, did come out on this. I emailed him and the whole of UWS to remind him that he should not rush to judgement only weeks after his arrival from Tasmania via Northumbria when, in Scotland, we’d had universal, free education from bairns to graduates, for about 500 years. I quoted John Knox on this for the first time in the history of email at UWS!

Another failed journalism assignment by Herald staff?

 

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Herald headline distorts their own report to suggest that it should have read ‘No leading academic questions Scotland’s flagship free education policy’

  1. johnrobertson834 September 16, 2018 / 9:03 am

    NOTE: principals and senior academics are not necessarily ‘leading academics’. They are more educational managers motivated by income and the consequent increase in their salaries and bonuses. Leading academics are generally professors or the like who have done research into education.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. John September 16, 2018 / 2:21 pm

    You put names to statements John , unlike the uninspiring Herald, doing this thing that the Scottish media do of proclaiming “a source said ” , ” academics claim ” , “a spokesman for the union said ” . If they would name their sources these people could be queried by others , if they are not named I believe they are just making it up as they go along ! .

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Contrary September 16, 2018 / 7:41 pm

    With something like this is it not really a bit weird to keep the sources’ names secret? As you say John, if they were really leading academics, do research on the subject, and really did have concerns, would they not put their names to the statements. Nomedia is really just taking the piss, they have the option to keep a source confidential, but that should not be used just so we can’t tell whether that source has any clue as to what they’re talking about or not. Nomedia are out of control, privileged, and shout freedom of speech when they are taken to task. There should be controls on what they say.

    Nice new headlining to the blog there John, nice colour scheme. Takes me back a bit, to Saturday morning tv when you might have the Lone Ranger, Champion the Wonder Horse (… Like a streak of lightning,,, like a mighty cannon ball he seemed to fly,,,), Zorro, and other delights all in a row (far better than swap shop!). Hope your heroism can stand up to the same rigours of those guys 😀

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s