Do Office for National Statistics figures reveals SNP rule is good for us? The Fraser Institute seems to agree


(c) Daily Telegraph 🙂

From the ONS yesterday:

Scotland is the only country to show improvements across any measures of personal well-being. Between the years ending December 2016 and 2017, improvements in worthwhile and happiness ratings in the UK were driven by Scotland, where average (mean) ratings also improved. Interestingly, average life satisfaction ratings also improved for Scotland; however, there were no significant changes for ratings of anxiety. No overall changes were reported for any measure of personal well-being in England, Wales or Northern Ireland.’

Looking back over the years 2011 to 2017, life satisfaction in Scotland rose steadily, year-on-year, from 7.51 to 7.72.

Now, of course, I’m not really claiming a direct causal relationship between SNP rule and a sense of well-being in Scots. Going by the Scotsman’s regular trolls, there are a number people really pissed-off with SNP rule. However, two important points are worth making.

First, if Scots had been shown to be less satisfied with life than others in the UK or if the trend had been downward, you can be sure the SNP would be getting the blame.

Second, there is clear evidence from research:

‘Happiness economics has shown that the degree to which people feel they are in control of their lives positively correlates with personal life satisfaction. In a parallel manner, economic freedom has been found to exert an independent impact on life satisfaction over and above the impact on per-capita income levels and other indicators of material well-being.’

Now this is from the Fraser Institute. No, not the ‘of Allander’ version much loved by Reporting Scotland and doom-sayers, across the country, but the Canadian one.

Again, I know their research is about individual economic control and personal life satisfaction, but our sense of individual economic control does not exist in a vacuum and, rather, exists within the much wider context of local and national political decision-making. I haven’t done any research on this, but I know that my own sense of individual economic control is diminished by the behaviour of my local authority and enhanced by the recent actions of the government in Holyrood.

One the one hand, South Ayrshire Council has wasted public funds which I contributed to in council tax, on ripping up a protected cycle path which I hoped to use, because of the pressure from self-interested overweight Tory car drivers. I may be over-generalising there but I’ve met one or two of them.

On the other hand, free University tuition for my children, free prescriptions for me and my family and my bus pass, to name just three factors, have surely had a quite direct effect on my individual economic control.

Of course, there is still room for improvement in my level of personal life satisfaction. Redundancies at Reporting Scotland as viewing figures are revealed, the final collapse of the Scotsman, Herald and Daily Record and the utter destruction of the Scottish Tories after this final betrayal over Brexit, would cheer me up no end.


8 thoughts on “Do Office for National Statistics figures reveals SNP rule is good for us? The Fraser Institute seems to agree

  1. John May 18, 2018 / 9:25 am

    Fraser Institute , had me confused until you clarified the difference as opposed to “of Allander ” , as they are the doom-sayers of everything Scottish , I was wondering if they had a brain swap . Good to see the level of happiness going up in Scotland , maybe we are finally getting to grips with a lot of social problems , but we know we still have a hill to climb . Don’t expect any of the Britnat press to report it , it’s a positive step in the right direction for Scotland and that is a reporting no-no as far as they are concerned !

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Molloy Harry M May 18, 2018 / 9:48 am

    John your column, has yet again made me smile and look forwards to a better day

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Alasdair Macdonald May 18, 2018 / 11:15 am

    An aside: re your comment about South Ayrshire Council and the segregated cycle route which they had to take out. While I am a strong advocate of increased cycling infrastructure, preferably created by reducing vehicular space on road carriageways, in this specific case removal of the lane was the correct decision. South Ayrshire had been very poor in their consultation process and the section of road chosen was not the best place to instal it and it did, indeed, present hazards to both cyclists and drivers. Not only did SAC have to take the infrastructure out, they also had to repay Sustrans the 50% of costs they had granted. Sadly, by its political ineptitude, SAC gave a hostage to fortune to the rabid car lobby – the people who DO NOT WANT PEDESTRIANS AND CYCLISTS ON THEIR ROADS!!!!
    Ayr and South Ayrshire really do need more segregated cycling infrastructure so that more people can enjoy the wonderful countryside and get a bit of exercise in much less polluted air.
    The endorphins released by cycling and walking undoubtedly – guaranteed! – are good for happiness and the soul as well as providing good exercise.


    • johnrobertson834 May 18, 2018 / 2:54 pm

      Thanks A. As a once regular cyclist on Holmston Road, I disagree. Drivers might get out of their cars if they were more inconvenienced. A segregated cycle route protects cyclists if motorists will slow down and respect it.

      A retired traffic policeman, I know, saw no hazards in the route if motorists were to respect it. Having gathered the remains of more than one dead cyclist off the road, he welcomed it without reservation.

      Only SAC have seen the need to rip-up a costly cycle lane.


  4. Toni Young May 18, 2018 / 8:21 pm

    Your final paragraph made me laugh and I agree 100% with the sentiment.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to John Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s