Herald propaganda goes biblical


‘Quick, the Curriculum for Excellence advisors are right behind us!’

(c) http://messianicapologetics.net

Under the headline:

‘Workload, stress and pay blamed for exodus of teachers at Scottish schools.’

we read:

‘A significant proportion of more experienced teachers have left the profession in Scotland since 2010. Schools have faced an exodus of their most experienced teachers over the past seven years at a time of unprecedented upheaval in the sector. Analysis of statistics from the Scottish Government show there has been a 21 per cent reduction in the number of teachers aged 45 and over since 2010 – accounting for some 5000 members of school staff.’


Once more, a deliberately (?) misleading headline and deliberate or confused use of statistics to try to construct a crisis out of nothing.

First, 21% of teachers over 45, leaving in 7 years is equivalent to around 3% per year – natural turnover or an exodus? The former I think. There are 51 500 teachers in Scottish schools. If we didn’t have that kind of retirement rate, what would be the point in training new teachers? Second, ‘exodus of teachers’ is used in the headline to imply teachers of all ages and experience when in fact we are only talking about older teachers. Third, to talk of ‘unprecedented upheaval’ is to reveal a lack of knowledge of the history of education in Scotland over the last 50 years. I remember well the very same melodramatic reaction to curriculum change in the 80s and 90s. Fourth, are younger teachers commonly less effective than older ones? I spent 30 years in teacher-training and, in visits to schools, met many highly-skilled, energetic and enthusiastic younger teachers who, also, were up-to-date with curriculum change and approved of it. I also met a few older teachers who had become negative, unenthusiastic and who were resistant to change, any change.

Finally, ‘workload and stress’ – Scottish schools are far better-staffed than those in England. The teacher-pupil ratio in Secondary schools is particularly generous.

There are now 543 more teachers in Scottish schools. In 2017, only 631 P1 pupils were taught in classes of more than 26 compared to 16 845 in 2006 at the end of the Lab/Lib Dem coalition.


There are 51 500 teachers in Scottish schools and the pupil/teacher ratio is now 13.6 pupils per teacher, down from (better than) 13.7 in 2016. This ratio is an important indicator of the time teachers have to engage with pupils and is likely to have played a major part in narrowing attainment gaps.


In England, there were 457 300 teachers in 2016, up by 400 from 2015. The pupil/teacher ratio in 2016 was 17.6 pupils per teacher. England’s population is almost exactly ten times that of Scotland, so you might have expected there to be around 515 000 teachers there. The increase of 400 teachers, in England, from 2015 to 2016, is small when compared with the Scottish Government’s increase of 543 between 2016 and 2017 in a country with a tenth of the population.


So, the pupil/teacher ratio in Scotland is significantly better than that in England. That must translate into more manageable workloads and reduced stress. I don’t deny the possibility that some are feeling over-worked and stressed but given the many positive factors in the job compared to many others in the economy, I seriously doubt an exodus. Have a word with nurses, cleaners, GPs, social workers and ask how many would like better conditions and get the same answers, or even more negative ones, as you would from teachers.


13 thoughts on “Herald propaganda goes biblical

  1. achmony January 13, 2018 / 10:40 am

    What lying bastards. Herald – be ashamed!


  2. achmony January 13, 2018 / 1:53 pm

    John Robertson. The SNP should be employing you to be their rebuttals manager. It is obvious that they are singularly unable (or for some obscure reason) unwilling to do this job themselves. Their policy on refuting the ghastly and untruthful attacks on them and all Independence-minded Scots, is frankly non-exsistant. Their passivity must end forthwith.


    • johnrobertson834 January 13, 2018 / 3:01 pm

      Thanks Achmony. I think the SNP HQ people find me a bit too combative and want to appear professional and calm. Since Salmond, the strategy is to stay positive and never get drawn into a fight.


  3. achmony January 13, 2018 / 4:39 pm

    Yes, I agree unfortunately. They could so easily win the fight because the opposition have absolutely no credence. Right is on the SNP side and to acquiesce so easily is unbecoming and so disappointing. I do hope their strategy pays off.

    Liked by 1 person

    • johnrobertson834 January 13, 2018 / 4:45 pm

      You’re right about the opposition. The NO campaign will have no coherence this time and their leadership will make Broon and Darling look good.


  4. Alan Gordon January 13, 2018 / 4:48 pm

    Thank you John for the breakdown.


  5. Alasdair Macdonald January 13, 2018 / 5:50 pm

    An excellent debunking. It is simple arithmetic.

    I suspect that this has been based on a press release by the EIS or SSTA in pursuance of their recently announced pay campaign seeking a marked salary rise.

    Had the Herald identified the source, then, such an article could be judged by readers in a context.


    • johnrobertson834 January 13, 2018 / 6:57 pm

      Yes BA Journalism, Year 1, Week 1, Day 1, 9.30am, workshop assessment – FAIL


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s