BBC 18, STV 7: ‘Weaponising’ Scotland’s Health Service: How BBC Scotland is developing a new Project Fear: Part 3: 1st to 31st January 2017


In the 27 days since January 4th, BBC Scotland has reported serious ‘problems’ in NHS Scotland 18 times! STV have only reported 7 times. I’ve dismantled nearly all of the BBC reports elsewhere on this site. Most were inaccurate, distorted or dramatized. Many were fed to the BBC by the Labour or Tory parties. The difference is marked – more than twice as many on BBC. This is clear evidence on the part of BBC Scotland to use (abuse?) NHS Scotland as a weapon with which to attack the SNP government, often on behalf of the other parties, despite the very real (researched- see below) risk of harm to potential patients, patients, relatives and staff, made highly anxious and/or demoralised by this cold-hearted campaign of distortion and lies.

I’ve been keeping a note, for Reporting Scotland and STV since 1st January 2017. I plan, of course to release a more full report later but I think there’s a place for interim reports so here’s the third. I’ll be comparing BBC and STV evening news broadcasts to use the latter as a kind of benchmark for what is reasonable and not openly anti-independence propaganda. I’m now fairly sure that STV have made a commercial decision not to drive away their many Yes-supporting viewers, in the interests of maintaining their advertising revenue.

I’ve discussed the actual flaws in the reports which make them clearly ‘scare stories’ rather than responsible news reporting, elsewhere on this site at:

From the 20th to the 31st of January we had a further three, one of which was echoed by STV giving the poor viewers of Reporting Scotland a total of 18 NHS Scotland scare stories in the space of only 27 days. STV only reported 7 in the same period.

The latest reports on BBC Scotland were:

23rd: Two health boards paid more than £1500 for an agency nurse to cover a single shift. This was provided by a Freedom of Information request form the Conservative Party who branded it ‘a slap in the face to NHS staff nurses.’

24th: ‘Hospital waiting times slightly improved but still below key targets’

26th: NHS Grampian says it can’t confirm when new dates will be given to patients for cancelled (sic) operations. The Health Board has postponed more than 100 procedures since the beginning of November.’

STV also covered the more objective story on the 24th. The other two were presumably not fed to it by opposition party sources or they didn’t think them newsworthy. I’ve dismantled the news value of the other two at:

After a month, the picture is now very clear. BBC Reporting Scotland remain, it seems, desperate to undermine the Scottish Government at every turn using, irresponsibly, NHS Scotland as a weapon.

The possible negative effects on potential patients, patients, relatives and staff, of this strategy, are discussed more fully and referenced with evidence at:

Is BBC Reporting Scotland’s ‘Weaponising’ of NHS Scotland likely to actually increase both physical and mental health problems?


6 thoughts on “BBC 18, STV 7: ‘Weaponising’ Scotland’s Health Service: How BBC Scotland is developing a new Project Fear: Part 3: 1st to 31st January 2017

  1. John February 1, 2017 / 4:07 pm

    You would think that elections were coming up the way they go on . They will just keep telling us how badly the SNP policies are working until we just vote Unionists , any unionists , into power . You will need to get a “fake news ” flag on all your articles John .

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Jack Collatin February 2, 2017 / 9:33 am

    I wonder why the Herald doesn’t just drop ‘Scotland’ from its title.It is clearly a English Establishment Unionist propaganda organism.
    After 5 years of taking the ‘paper I stopped during Indyref 1.
    I’ve scanned the online content today 2/2/17.
    Why not just have a blank front page with the banner:
    The Day of Reckoning is nigh for the Fourth Estate Fifth Column.

    Liked by 1 person

    • johnrobertson834 February 2, 2017 / 10:55 am

      Their behaviour seems either delusional (they believe they’re saving us) or psychopathic (they enjoy hurting us)?

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Alex Beveridge February 2, 2017 / 10:38 am

    Due to the first-class service my family and I have received over recent years, I have always contacted the hospitals concerned to express my thanks to all concerned in N.H.S Scotland. Most of this care happened at a hospital that would not exist if a Lab/LibDem administration had been returned to power in 2007.
    Despite this, one of the group, whose life was quite literally saved by surgeons at this hospital, is still a constant critic of our health service, believes everything reported on the B.B.C about the S.N.H.S, and will still vote Labour, and No to independence in Indyref2.
    Will they ever change? I doubt it.


    • johnrobertson834 February 2, 2017 / 10:41 am

      Wrong procedure? Yes, the treatment I’ve had, all excellent, would have cost me the house in the USA.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s